Print
In Other News

Corrosion Likely Cause Of Grace Street Facade Collapse

By Emma Dill, posted Mar 22, 2024
Corrosion likely caused the March 7 collapse of a facade on Grace Street in downtown Wilmington. At least two of the impacted businesses have since reopened. (Photo by Emma Dill)
Corrosion appears to have caused the collapse of a facade on Grace Street earlier this month, according to an engineer who reviewed the aftermath.

The exterior facade, which collapsed on March 7, runs above the storefronts that house Taco Baby, Kat 5 Kava and Rumcow. While the collapse forced initial closures, some of the businesses have since reopened.

Within days of the collapse, E.B. Pannkuk, president of local firm Stature Engineering, reviewed the building with building owner Bruce Umstetter. Umstetter has owned the building since 1984, according to property records. The building near the corner of Grace and S. Second Streets was built in 1940. 

Although Pannkuk’s firm didn’t perform a formal failure evaluation, a review found that a “steel window lintel weakened by corrosion” appears to have contributed to the collapse.

“We did observe one area of the lintel that was displaced,” Pannkuk wrote in an email to the Business Journal. “Eye witness accounts appear to support our assumption.”

Following the collapse, Project Grace contractor Monteith Construction received questions about whether the site’s ongoing work could have affected the nearby facade, Monteith President Bryan Thomas told the Business Journal last week. 

“We don’t think there's any tie to it,” Thomas said, adding that the site has several measures in place to limit vibrations.

Monteith has worked on renovations of about 20 downtown buildings over the years, Thomas said, and it’s not uncommon for aging facades to have problems.

“What we've seen on old buildings is just years of water intrusions, and ultimately, that just starts to break down the brick and the ties that hold the brick to the facades,” he said last week.

It’s “doubtful” construction in the area contributed to the collapse, according to Pannkuk.

“A vibration with the strength to damage adjacent buildings would have to be incredibly strong,” Pannkuk wrote. “We do recommend that buildings have a third-party testing company document the existing condition of adjacent buildings. This documentation goes a long way toward settling debates over construction damage.”

He added that periodic building evaluations by an engineer with experience in historic construction could have made the facade collapse less likely.

“This could be an issue in other buildings in downtown Wilmington,” Pannkuk wrote. “Building owners should have their building reviewed to improve general building maintenance.”
Ico insights

INSIGHTS

SPONSORS' CONTENT
Burrus rob headshot 300x300

Real Estate Markets Yesterday and Today

Robert Burrus - Cameron School of Business - UNC-Wilmington
Screenshot2022 01 06at338 162234623

Food is the Foundation for Prosperous Communities

Girard Newkirk - Genesis Block
Bovio ernie ceo 240207 head 712412398

One to Grow On – A Look at My First Year at the Coast

Ernie Bovio - New Hanover Regional Medical Center Novant Health

Trending News

Commercial Real Estate Firm Expands Into Wilmington

Emma Dill - Feb 11, 2025

MedNorth Breaks Ground On Clinic Expansion

Emma Dill - Feb 10, 2025

UNCW Business School Grads Launching App

Cece Nunn - Feb 10, 2025

WMPO Board Re-elects Officers

Staff Reports - Feb 11, 2025

Endowment Announces New Roles, Research And Impact Department

Staff Reports - Feb 11, 2025

In The Current Issue

Officials Count Film Dollars, Challenges

The growth of Wilmington’s film industry since the 1980s, when Dino De Laurentiis built his studio here, has not been steady or even predict...


City (and Former City) Properties Performing New Functions

The Thalian Hall space is one of several properties vacated by the city in recent years, following the move to Skyline Center. While the cit...


Homebuilder Finds Room To Grow Here

“It’s not a huge market, but it’s not a small market either. There’s enough room for us to have a presence.”...

Book On Business

The 2024 WilmingtonBiz: Book on Business is an annual publication showcasing the Wilmington region as a center of business.

Order Your Copy Today!


Galleries

Videos

2024 Power Breakfast: The Next Season